Everton
| Stekelenburg |
| Coleman |
| Jagielka |
| Williams |
| Baines |
| McCarthy (Funes Mori 90) |
| Gueye |
| Barkley |
| E Valencia (Calvert-Lewin 79) |
| R Lukaku |
| Lennon (Mirallas 68) |
Arsenal
| Cech |
| Bellerín |
| Gabriel |
| Koscielny |
| Monreal |
| Coquelin (Pérez 88) |
| Xhaka |
| Walcott (Giroud 71) |
| Özil |
| Oxlade-Chamberlain (Iwobi 71) |
| Sánchez |